Choose the notebook before comparing brands
Ryder Carroll’s Bullet Journal guidance does not require a special notebook. A plain one works if you can add an index and find your entries later. Numbered pages save setup time; thick paper may matter if you use markers; a smaller format is easier to carry but gives less space for layouts. Test your own pen on an inconspicuous page—paper weight alone cannot predict every ink result.
Five notebooks for different uses
Official Bullet Journal Edition 2: ready-made method pages
The official Edition 2 has a dot grid, numbered pages, a Bullet Key, Index and Future Log, plus a grid guide and bookmarks. Its listed 120 gsm paper is thicker than many basic notebooks. Choose it if you want the method’s starting pages prepared for you. The extra structure is less valuable if you prefer to build everything yourself.
Scribbles That Matter Pro: choose a paper weight
The Pro dotted journal lists a 120 gsm and a 160 gsm paper option, numbered pages, key and index pages, and a pen-test page. That gives you a choice between a lighter writing setup and heavier paper for more elaborate spreads. Select the exact paper variant before buying; the product name alone does not identify it.
Archer & Olive dot grid: art-focused pages
Archer & Olive’s dot-grid collection lists 160 gsm paper and several sizes and page counts. It may suit a journal used for illustration as well as tasks. Check the particular cover and format for the page count and grid you want; “A5” does not mean every listing is identical. If you mostly use a ballpoint pen and short daily logs, thick paper may add bulk without much benefit.
Dingbats Earth Collection: A5+ format
Dingbats’ Earth Collection lists an A5+ size and 100 gsm cream paper, with dotted pages and a lay-flat binding. The larger-than-A5 footprint gives you room for layouts but may not fit a compact bag or notebook cover. Check the specific design and its current materials claim on the maker’s listing rather than assuming every range is the same.
Moleskine Classic dotted: smaller size choices
Moleskine’s 2026 Classic notebook catalogue lists dotted versions in several sizes, with 70 gsm paper, a ribbon and an inner pocket. The Pocket and Medium formats suit short notes on the move; the Large gives more room for a monthly log. Lighter paper can show writing on the reverse, so test the pens and markers you intend to use.
Which differences matter in practice?
If you want to begin with the Index and Future Log already laid out, Edition 2 is the clearest fit. If paper choice is central, compare the Scribbles That Matter variants with Archer & Olive’s heavier pages. If carrying the book daily matters more than decorative spreads, look closely at the dimensions of Moleskine’s smaller sizes. Dingbats A5+ suits someone who wants a little more page area. None of these comparisons is a claim of first-hand pen testing or durability.
Check the manufacturer’s current listing for the exact variant, page count, availability and price before buying; those details change. A notebook you already own is a sensible starting point. Set up an index, future log, monthly log and daily log, then add collections only when you need them. Our Bullet Journal Method guide explains that setup.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need the official Bullet Journal notebook?
No. The method works in an ordinary notebook. The official Edition 2 saves setup time with numbered pages and prepared method sections.
Is dotted paper necessary for bullet journaling?
No. Dots can guide layouts without ruled lines, but a lined, grid or blank notebook can hold an index and logs. Choose the format you will use.
What paper weight is good for markers?
Thicker paper is often worth considering for markers, but performance also depends on the ink and paper finish. Check the exact variant and test your own pen on a spare page.
Are numbered pages useful in a bullet journal?
Yes, if you use an index to find entries. You can also number pages by hand in an unnumbered notebook.
What size bullet journal should I choose?
A smaller notebook is easier to carry, while A5 or larger gives more space for logs and drawings. Measure your bag and consider how much you write each day.
Can I start bullet journaling with a notebook I already own?
Yes. Reserve a few pages for an index, add a future and monthly log, then begin daily entries. Buy a different notebook only when a specific limitation matters.
Lorelei has been an online entrepreneur, marketer and writer since 2006. Her biggest passion is WordPress, which is why she switched to being a full-time blogger 20 years ago and hasn’t looked back since. With so many years of experience behind her, she is an expert in copywriting, SEO, marketing and business strategies.
